UPDATE: Court Vacates DHS Rule Ending Duration of Status (D/S) for F, J, and I Nonimmigrants (November 16, 2026)

1. What Happened?

In September, the court temporarily paused the DHS rule. This ruling goes further. On November 16, 2026, the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts granted the plaintiffs' motion for summary judgment and vacated the DHS final rule that would have eliminated Duration of Status (D/S) for F, J, and I nonimmigrants. The September order was temporary relief while the case continued. This ruling is a final decision on the merits, and it sets aside the rule entirely.

As a result, F-1 students and J-1 exchange visitors remain under the existing D/S framework, and there is no fixed four-year limit on admission.

2. How Did We Get Here?

•     July 17, 2026: DHS published the final rule (91 Fed. Reg. 44976). It was scheduled to take effect on September 15.

•     August 18, 2026: A coalition of higher education associations and labor unions filed suit and moved for preliminary relief.

•     September 14, 2026: The court issued nationwide preliminary relief, barring DHS and ICE from implementing the rule.

•     September 30, 2026: The government appealed that order to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit (No. 26-2112).

•     November 3, 2026: The government asked the First Circuit to hold the appeal for 30 days. The court granted the request on November 13.

•     November 16, 2026: The district court granted the plaintiffs' motion for summary judgment, denied the government's cross-motion, and vacated the final rule.

The case is Presidents' Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration et al. v. DHS (D. Mass.), before U.S. District Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV.

3. Why Did the Court Strike Down the Rule?

The court held that the rule was arbitrary and capricious under the Administrative Procedure Act (5 U.S.C. §706(2)). According to the court, DHS:

•     Did not adequately weigh the rule's costs and benefits;

•     Did not substantiate its stated concerns about fraud and national security;

•     Did not adequately consider alternatives, such as greater use of SEVIS;

•     Did not respond to many public comments; and

•     Exceeded its authority under the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) by restricting students' ability to change programs and schools.

DHS asked the court, in the alternative, to send the rule back to the agency without vacating it (remand without vacatur), or to limit relief to the plaintiffs. The court declined. Citing the long history of the D/S policy, it vacated the rule in full.

4. What Does This Mean for F-1 Students?

The new framework described in our July post is not in effect. Specifically:

•     Your I-94 will continue to show "D/S," with no fixed expiration date.

•     If you need more time to complete your program, your DSO may extend your I-20 as before (8 C.F.R. §214.2(f)(7)). You do not need to file Form I-539 with USCIS.

•     The proposed restrictions do not apply. These include the first-year bar on transfers and changes of major, the limits on graduate students changing schools, and the bar on enrolling in a second program at the same or a lower degree level. Transfers remain governed by existing regulations (8 C.F.R. §214.2(f)(8)).

•     The grace period after completing your program remains 60 days (8 C.F.R. §214.2(f)(5)(iv)).

•     OPT and STEM OPT continue under the existing regulations and procedures.

5. Does D/S Mean You Can Stay Indefinitely?

No. As we explained in September, a student who stops attending school or works without authorization may already be out of status, even if the I-94 says "D/S" (8 C.F.R. §214.2(f)(5)(i)). Being out of status can lead to removal proceedings. It can also cause problems with reinstatement, OPT, change or extension of status, and adjustment of status.

Unlawful presence is still calculated under the existing rules. Generally, it begins only after USCIS formally finds a status violation while adjudicating a benefit request, or after an immigration judge issues a removal order. Departing after more than 180 days of unlawful presence can trigger a 3-year bar, and more than one year can trigger a 10-year bar (INA §212(a)(9)(B)).

6. Could the Rule Still Come Back?

Possibly. This ruling may not be the final word.

•     As of this writing, we have not confirmed whether the government has appealed the final judgment. In a case where the federal government is a party, a notice of appeal is due within 60 days of judgment (Fed. R. App. P. 4(a)(1)(B)). Here, that deadline falls on or about January 15, 2027.

•     Because the final judgment supersedes the September preliminary order, the pending First Circuit appeal of that order may become moot.

•     Unless the judgment is stayed or reversed on appeal, the existing D/S framework remains in place.

•     Even if the government ultimately prevails, the rule would not automatically apply retroactively. Any new effective date, transition provisions, and unlawful presence calculations would depend on future court orders and DHS guidance.

7. What Should You Do Now?

•     Don't rush. Do not file Form I-539 or change your enrollment or transfer plans in anticipation of the new rule.

•     Continue to maintain F-1 status: full-time enrollment, CPT and OPT employment only as authorized, and timely address reporting.

•     Review your most recent I-94, all I-20s, and your SEVIS record with your DSO.

•     If you may have a status violation, received a prior USCIS denial, or plan to travel abroad or attend a consular interview, get an individual legal review before you leave the United States or file a new application.

•     Watch for news of a government appeal and for guidance from your school's international student office. We will post updates as the case develops.

Judy Chang Law Firm, National Immigration Law Firm
Copyright© Judy J. Chang, Esq. All rights reserved. 11/19/2026
The information contained in article is provided for general information only and should not serve as a substitute for legal advice.
http://www.judychanglaw.com / contact@judychanglaw.com

Jenny ParkComment